Work Related Education Deduction – MBA Tuition Deduction

By Alex Oware on 03/24/2017 10:00 AM

Work Related Education Deduction Ð MBA Tuition Deduction

The IRS has always argued that an M.B.A. degree automatically trains you for a new profession. So IRS does not take it lightly when you deduct M.B.A. costs as unreimbursed employee business expenses or as self-employed business expenses.

Thankfully, the Tax Court does not have the same attitude. The Tax court has on numerous occasions argued and uphold MBA tuition deductions, the precedence set by the tax courts establishes that business deductions are allowed if the MBA training maintains or improves skills used in your current job, profession, or business.

To Qualify, you must meet 3 requirements:

(1)

Your education must maintain or improve your skills in your pre-grad occupation.   If you worked in the same industry both before and after graduate school, your pre-grad occupation had some managerial duties, and your MBA courses related to your previous occupation, you have a better case for the deduction.

 

-OR-

 

Your education must be required by your employer, or by law or regulations, to keep your present salary, status, or job.   You have a better case for claiming the deduction if your employer requested you to get the MBA (and have a letter to support that). 

 

 

(2)

The education must not be needed to meet the minimum requirements for a trade or business.  To become a doctor, you must go to medical school, to become a lawyer, you must go to law school.   For these occupations, the education would not be deductible as a business expense because the education is the minimum requirement.  However, it is possible to work in management or finance, etc., without an advanced degree, so expenses to obtain an MBA degree could possibly qualify.

 

 

(3)

The education must not qualify you for a new job, trade, or business.   If you had limited managerial and/or business duties in your occupation prior to getting your MBA, (less than one or two years of business experience), your MBA might be construed as qualifying you for a new trade or business, and would therefore not be deductible.

 

If you are an employee, a change of duties that involves the same general kind of work is not a new trade or business.  However, the overwhelming reality is that the majority of the court decisions focus on the final one: if an education prepares or qualifies a taxpayer for a new trade or business, no deduction is permitted.

 

The following are instances where the IRS disallowed the MBA expense deduction, but the courts ruled against IRS.

 

¯  Alex Kopaigora, a 42-year-old executive MBA student at Brigham Young University, decided to deduct $18,879 from his taxes for tuition and commuting. Unfortunately for Kopaigora, the IRS didnÕt agree with his tax return. The IRS cited the fact that he was unemployed for several months of that year as a reason to come after him for thousands of dollars.

 

The Tax Court judge disagreed, ruling that because Kopaigora had actively sought employment in his field for the remainder of his time at BYU a search that paid off when he was hired by a small California-based finance firm shortly after graduating he was entitled to the deductions.

 

 

¯  Lori Singleton-Clarke is a nurse who brought her own case to Tax Court after IRS refused to allow her to deduct her MBA. She was pursuing an MBA with a specialization in health care management. IRS disallowed $14,787 in education expenses on her 2005 tax return. The court ruled in favor of the Taxpayer by concurring with the TaxpayerÕs argument that she is using her skills as a nurse but needed the business knowledge as well.

 

The following are instances where the IRS disallowed the MBA expense deduction, and the courts ruled in favor of IRS

 

¯  Taxpayers, Adam Edward Hart and Lisa Denning Hart, claimed a miscellaneous itemized deduction on their 2009 tax return for Adam HartÕs MBA tuition of $18,600, reported on a Form 1098-T issued by Rollins College. After applying the 2% AGI threshold, the resulting itemized deduction for the taxpayers was $17,138, which resulted in a tax savings of $2,572.

 Judge Kathleen Kerrigan found that Adam Hart was not established in a trade or business BEFORE enrolling in the MBA program and disallowed the deduction.

The Key here is to have a job and a solid working history prior to enrolling in an MBA course, if youÕre planning of taking advantage of this huge deduction. However, rules are subject to varying interpretations, the IRS has increased its audits in this area.

 

Will I be Audited for taking this deduction?

It is likely that the IRS will question whether

a) you still had a trade or business if you took time off for school

 b) the education qualified you for a new trade or business and/or

(c) the education truly improved your skills in the trade or business you had before entering graduate school or if it should be considered personal enrichment and thus nondeductible. For the last item, they may look at specific coursework to see if it directly relates to your business.

 

Is your CPA Available for Audit Help?

Yes, if you need our CPA to advise or represent you in case of audit, our billing rate is $300 per hour. 

Should I Claim the Deduction?

Since obtaining an MBA can be very costly, claiming a business deduction for it can be a great tax savings.  The downside is that such a large deduction draws the attention of the IRS and in the past couple of years, the audit rate for education deductions has increased substantially.  

However, if you feel confident that you meet the criteria for claiming the deduction, the worst case is that your deduction is later disallowed and you have to pay back the tax you saved from claiming the deduction, plus interest and late penalties from the filing date.

Whether to claim the deduction is really a personal choice based on the criteria above as well as your own level of risk tolerance.  We cannot make the decision for you.  We can provide you consulting based on your personal situation and circumstances.

When Must I Claim the Deduction?

The expenses must be deducted in the year you paid them.  This includes costs paid using loan funds.  If your income in that year is less than your deduction, you will generate a net operating loss which can be carried forward to reduce your taxable income in the next year.  Net operating losses can be carried forward up to 20 years until used up.

What are the Chances of Being Audited?

Audit rates in general are low, but the risk for the work related education deduction seems moderate at this time.  The higher your education expenses deducted in one year, especially if you have low or no income in that year, the greater the risk.

What Proof is Needed to Defend an Audit?

You should obtain a letter from your employer (pre and post MBA) stating that the education was a necessary to maintain or improve your skills.  Make sure the employer does not state that the MBA is a standard requirement for your field (this could be construed by the IRS agent as a minimum requirement, and therefore making your education nondeductible).

It's been quoted by some IRS agents that , "If the individual cannot establish that the MBA led to an improvement in her already-existing skills the Court will disallow the deduction."  Also, proof of that the expenses were incurred will be requested.  You should have receipts from the school's bursar's office, bookstore, etc. to substantiate the amounts claimed.  Other possibilities could include a resume, a listing of courses taken, and details of duties in your jobs before and after school.

Where is the tuition deducted on my tax return?

On Schedule A as an Employee Business Expense (details on Form 2106) which is an itemized deduction subject to the 2% of AGI (adjusted gross income) floor for miscellaneous itemized deductions.  The 2% floor means that you can deduct only the amount in excess of 2% of your adjusted gross income.  Other limitations to itemized deductions may also apply and you can only take itemized deductions if they exceed the standard deduction.

For more information, see IRS Publication - Tax Benefits for Work Related Education.


***Disclaimer: I am a tax accountant and a CPA , but I am not your accountant or advocate (Unless you have signed up to my services). This communication is not intended as tax advice, and no tax accountant -client relationship results**